Staying Home for Eid: What You Can Do

Eid Sweets

By Samia Shameem

Lately, various petitions have been circulating around the country, calling on the Obama administration to recognize Muslim holidays within public schools. While the fact that Muslims are taking the initiative to have their voices heard is commendable, it’ll prove beneficial to discuss a few points:

1. The federal government does not monitor or regulate school closings and holidays. This task is appointed to a smaller system: local government, and more specifically, school boards. Even federal holidays are subject to the board’s discretion and are not imposed by the federal government. So a White House petition, though refreshingly ambitious, may be a bit too ambitious. An issue of this sort is much better taken care of by addressing one school at a time.

2. There are some things many of us may believe to be our rights as American citizens, such as the freedom to say how we feel, worship who we want, and be served equally by the judicial system regardless of where we come from. However, school holidays are not really a matter of civil rights. Making up less than 1% of the American population, Muslims should not be quick to label the lack of Eid recognition in the academic setting as an act of prejudice.

Here’s an example: In Pakistan, all schools observe Eid-ul-Adha, the celebration of Abraham’s sacrifice, and Eid-ul-Fitr, the celebration marking the end of the holy month of Ramadan. Being the second largest Muslim country in the world (Muslims make up a whopping 97% of the population), it would be questionable for schools to remain open on these two major Muslim holidays while remaining open on Christmas, a Christian holiday.

We are not being forced to choose between our religious and academic commitments, but, being one of the minorities in America, we most certainly have an underhand. Schools do not make these decisions based on its students’ imaan, or faith, but solely on their academic achievement. Depending on each region, holding classes on Eid may not disrupt the school day in the slightest regarding the number of absentees, while holding classes on Christmas would most likely leave schools in America barren.

The Solution? Let’s take a look…

Possibly unknown to many, there are a few school districts that do close in observance of Muslim holidays:

      Burlington, Vermont
      Cambridge, Massachusetts
      Paterson, New Jersey
      Trenton, New Jersey
      Dearborn, Michigan
      Skokie, Illinois

As you may notice, four of these six cities reside along the east coast (within the eastern-most states in the U.S.). The other two cities are in the Midwest.

Here’s the breakdown:
Land Percentage

When it comes to land, the Eastern States make up a mere 5% of the United States. Respectively–Midwest, 21%; South, 25%; and West, 49%. When we shift the lens towards the Muslim-American demographic, this is what we get:

Muslim Distribution
The weight has significantly shifted–East, 29%; Midwest, 22%; South, 32%; and West, 18%.

As you can see, ≈30% of the Muslim-American populace lives on 5% of American land (in the East). It is no wonder as to why the majority of the schools that have adopted Muslim holidays in their calendars are located there. Similarly, Dearborn, Michigan, also known as “America’s Muslim Capital”, has been observing Muslim holidays in their school calendar for the past decade.

David Mustonen, the Director of Community and Public Relations in Dearborn, gladly walks me through the evolution.

“As the Muslim population increased in the Dearborn area, “ Mustonen tells me, “it became necessary to include Muslim holidays in the school calendar. We serve the community we are in.”

As many may already know, Islam follows the lunar calendar, therefore all holy days are determined based on the sighting of the moon. However, there is much conflict in regards to how the moon is sighted and how legitimate either technique is–with the naked eye or by use of calculations and technology. This is referred to as the “moon sighting controversy” and has become a source of debate within communal and academic conversations.

PicMonkey Collage Eid

When asked how the Dearborn’s school district handles this conflict, Mustonen takes a moment to suppress his hearty laughter.  ”There are four to five local mosques,” he joyfully explains, “and, depending on which imam you talk to, we try to find what appears to be the consensus. Sometimes even two days are taken off, in case of any discrepancies within the community.”
Just as boards of education should be, the school board in Dearborn was objectively focused on, as Mustonen says, “better serving the community.”

Much more locally (13 miles from Downtown Chicago to be exact), Skokie School District 68 included Eid-ul-Adha in their 2013-2014 calendar. Superintendent France McTague’s remarks:

“This was the first year I’ve been approached by a parent as to why we take two Jewish days off and no Muslim day off.”

His statement reflects on the lack of communication between communities and their respective schools. It also shows us how one voice can make the difference.

So… What can you do?

Say something.

Whether it takes the form of an email, phone call, local petition, or a visit to your local school, if there is something that affects you or your children, make sure you have your voice heard. There’s a high likelihood that there are others in your community who feel the same way. Talk to your community and collaborate—remember, there is power in numbers. White house petitions are great, but a lot of times you don’t need to reach very far to cash in your two cents.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Chicago Monitor’s editorial policy.

 

7 Responses to Staying Home for Eid: What You Can Do

  1. Ozai says:

    I totally agree with you. Even though petitions are great, it usually is better to talk to your local community and talk to schools regarding how you feel. Not only is this faster, but it will also be implemented quicker. :)

  2. daily reader says:

    The article is very thought provoking and mentions the strong need for the Obama Administration to consider and/or accept this petition. The demographics that the author provided highlight the reasons as to why his petition should be approved which is great. The hard work of the Muslim community, like the author mentioned, is commendable.

  3. Bugeyes says:

    Good perspective and I agree with your perspective. Addressing the issue by talking to the local communities can cetainly benifit the cause of action.

  4. Nour says:

    Honestly? I feel that it is the schools duty to know their community and as David Mustonen mentioned .. the should ultimately serve the community they are in. Great article! I wasn’t aware of schools actually taking off for Muslim holidays!

  5. Fatima says:

    I never thought about it this way! When I first came across the White House petition I right away jumped on it, but now that you bring up all these points, it makes much more sense to take a smaller, local approach. I hope I can start something in my area :)

  6. Bilal Hussain says:

    Twice a year I am forced to listen to the same discussion regarding the Muslim community and how it is incredibly divided with the celebration of Eid. It is a discussion that I know is going to occur. So I make sure I have my ear plugs or headphones in hand.

    Overall, I thought this article did a good job of shedding some light on the Eid dilemma. Yet, I do not think that Eid will be considered a school holiday any time soon, or ever. Many Muslims do not even celebrate Eid the same day as one another, so why should Eid be recognized as a school holiday?

    • Samia Shameem says:

      It is quite frustrating–we want to integrate within society and gain recognition, yet we aren’t able to come together to make decisions within our own community. But I don’t think that in itself is reason enough for us to not have our voices heard in other settings. Observing Muslim holidays in schools makes Islam less alien and helps others acknowledge and get familiar with the religion; people are often scared of what they don’t understand. But your argument is definitely a valid one and I appreciate the feedback. :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>